Wow, Ranarama... I'd forgotten about that
Interesting game - one of the games that came with my first ST.
Probably the first games I played on the ST before that though were Carrier Command, Stargoose, Dungeon Master (all of these were great, but I never had time to play them much since they were on my friend's computer in 1990... I only had a C64 at the time - go Midnight Resistance, Sly Spy and Shadow Warriors!).
After I got my own ST(s), I played the PD game "Fatemaster" most, followed by... hmm, maybe No Second Prize, Saint Dragon (which was bloody hard - never got very far in it without cheating), Microprose Grand Prix (probably the only original I ever bought on the ST)... Pang and Puzznic.
There's loads of other games I enjoyed, but it's hard to remember. Probably easier to visualise the pirate menus than the games they contained
In fact, I usually enjoyed ordering PD disks, then rummaging around on them when they arrived, reading the docs and stuff on the various utility disks and playing with GFA Basic. They were fun days when a bubble-wrapped envelope holding 8 disks would arrive in the post and it was the most exciting thing in months