JohnLeather wrote:Almost everything broken here! My Atari ST Joystick doesn't work going left. I think the day that Joystick broke was when I called it a day and never went back to the ST since. I've opened it up and the plastic bit pushing the contact pads is cracked. It works when pressing the contact pad by hand but it cumbersome to use making it completely unplayable.
I went through a ton of joysticks in my ST days. I found that the 'official' black Atari joysticks with the red fire button (as originally seen on the 2600 console) broke pretty easily.

The 'inner stick' part that pressed on the contacts was made of thick nylon or something and the plastic ring around the base of the stick was easy to break playing games that required lots of 'waggling'.
The best ones I found to use were Competition Pro or Zipstick (which were very similar)

as they had microswitches instead of the 'clicky contacts' on the circuit board (Which quite often fell apart or 'caved in', making the joystick useless.)
Their 'achilles heel' was the molded sheath where the wire went into the joystick. Quite often the wires would break at the end of the molding or inside it, meaning that if you wanted to salvage the joystick, you had to cut that piece out, strip the wires further down and re-solder them to the contacts. Without the 'sheath' part though (which was fastened into the body of the joystick, and actually did a fairly good job of stopping the wire from moving) your soldering job wouldn't last long and the wires would rip off the contacts when the joystick fell off the table or something (no matter how many clever things you did with blu-tac, cable ties, etc.)
The 'Quickshot II' was another good one (And had microswitches as well - the original Quickshot had the 'clicky pads')

This was especially good for 'wagglers' as it had suckers on the base, so you could secure it pretty securely to a flat surface and 'go for your life'..
(I say 'pretty securely' - I remember a couple of times when myself or one of my mates went flying for getting over-enthusiastic on a waggling game and the joystick came loose..)
I've also knocked a few joysticks together from component pieces of the broken ones.
Those tended to work for a little while, but I can't think of any that had much longevity - except for one that my Dad put together for me from the joystick mechanism of a 'Scramble' arcade cabinet for the stick, the volume control box and record reject button from an NSM jukebox (reject button was the fire button) and the wires from a dead Speccy joystick.
It worked pretty well - it would have been perfect, except the 'Scramble' stick didn't do diagonals very well, so it wasn't much use for games that needed 'up-left' and 'up-right' commands to jump..
You can still find them around - there's a chain of stores here in Canada called 'Value Village' - they're basically a big jumble sale. People donate stuff they don't want any more and the store cleans it up and sells it on cheap, and makes donations to charities, etc. I've seen plenty of old 8 & 16 bit computer joysticks in there for like $3 apiece - quite a few Sega Megadrive/Genesis pads as well, which have basically the same wiring (far as I remember).